Which is better........

Band of Brothers · **Which is better........ -** 05-02-2003, 06:02 PM

Which rifle is better,

ADD REASONS AND COMMENTS PLEASE

Cpl Luz · 05-02-2003, 06:04 PM

Enfield has good power and accuracy, poor reloading speed
Nagant is quick for reloading and a little less weak

Dont take my word for it i usually use M1

Hobbes · 05-03-2003, 12:38 AM

Quite simple the Nagent hits with the same power of a sniper rifle.

The Lee Enfeild has the same power the mauser.

[Bandit]Shifty|Manual{FD} · 05-07-2003, 10:26 AM

Lee enfield any day, quite simply because it has 10 rounds /clip, it doesnt matter if the nagant is the same power of a sniper, 1 hit to the upper chest with the lee will kill anyway it wont matter if its over kill like the sniper they both the the job done! also the nagant may reload a little bit faster since the nagant has to reload twice when the lee only needs to once, it more than compensates for the reload speed.

LoneGunner87 · 05-07-2003, 10:32 AM

I would say Garand is better. biggrin:

[Bandit]Shifty|Manual{FD} · 05-07-2003, 10:39 AM

m1 garand is for peeps who think they are good and superior to smg players, sure it does require more skill but all it is is a 8 round smg a true rifle player is embarassed to be even SEEN with an m1, mauser, lee or nagant are the only way to go. P.S , im a lee player

Tiwaz · 05-07-2003, 12:08 PM

[quote="Bandit_Yo-mama":1edf9]m1 garand is for peeps who think they are good and superior to smg players, sure it does require more skill but all it is is a 8 round smg a true rifle player is embarassed to be even SEEN with an m1, mauser, lee or nagant are the only way to go. P.S , im a lee player[/quote:1edf9]

That is baloni. A KAR/Mosin/Lee requires more skill than a Garand does, I'll admit that. Comparing it to an SMG is nonsense. Certainly in realism and/or Spearhead. SMG to Garand is like Vodka is to beer.

Tiwaz · 05-07-2003, 12:09 PM

And like MoHAA is to Spearhead.

I voted M1 Garand, biggrin:

Cpl Luz · 05-07-2003, 12:18 PM

When i first got spearhead, i was told the M1 is like for beginners and people who dont want to use SMG, Enfield and Nagant i was told were very similar but nagant was more accurate and Enfield was more accurate,
dont take my word for it though, personally i prefer the Enfield.
I know a real good rifleman with the nagant but not so many with the Enfield.

Cpl Luz · 05-07-2003, 12:19 PM

*EDIT*
.......nagant was more accurate and Enfield was more powerful

[MOD]Gen.WikiWeaponn · 05-07-2003, 07:38 PM

It seems that the nagant is just a smidgen more powerful than the kar, but accuracy is the exact same with a good crosshair (I have a one pixel dot croshair) but enfield is very very nice because you get 10 shots cool:

[Bandit]Shifty|Manual{FD} · 05-08-2003, 09:30 AM

im an enfield rifleman, i consider myself to be a good one too, ive tried the nagant, but honestly, even though the nagant has a more powerful round, if you hit him in the chest it wont make a idfference if its more powerful or not, both will kill.

that said, in the heat of battle being able to kill by hitting somone in the lower abdomen is a plus because its easier to get the kill. but even with this, i'd take the enfield anyday, even if it had a 5 round clip, id still take it cause theres something abotu it thats bitchin.

Unknown_Sniper · 05-09-2003, 11:22 PM

I like the enfield. Its accurate, powerful and has a large magazine compacity. I am also really good with it or some reason

Impala_Cavalier · 05-13-2003, 03:55 PM

[quote="Bandit_Yo-mama":983d1]m1 garand is for peeps who think they are good and superior to smg players, sure it does require more skill but all it is is a 8 round smg a true rifle player is embarassed to be even SEEN with an m1, mauser, lee or nagant are the only way to go. P.S , im a lee player[/quote:983d1]

I don't really think you can really say that about an M1. I always find it very interesting how a skilled M1 soldier can kill a man in 1 or 2 shots and in many cases it takes a full clip of ammo for a skilled soldier to kill with a Thompson. It's also just a question of realism, in WWII only the selected few in a unit used SMG's and most people used the M1. In AA or SH almost everyone uses a Thompson. most people I've seen play online rely to heavy on the [see enemy hold firing button and hope the bullets hit the enemy method.] swordfight:

Impala_Cavalier · 05-13-2003, 03:57 PM

[quote="Bandit_Yo-mama":a6514]m1 garand is for peeps who think they are good and superior to smg players, sure it does require more skill but all it is is a 8 round smg a true rifle player is embarassed to be even SEEN with an m1, mauser, lee or nagant are the only way to go. P.S , im a lee player[/quote:a6514]

I don't really think you can really say that about an M1. I always find it very interesting how a skilled M1 soldier can kill a man in 1 or 2 shots and in many cases it takes a full clip of ammo for a skilled soldier to kill with a Thompson. It's also just a question of realism, in WWII only the selected few in a unit used SMG's and most people used the M1. In AA or SH almost everyone uses a Thompson. most people I've seen play online rely to heavy on the [see enemy hold firing button and hope the bullets hit the enemy method.]