[Quik]

These two guys are NOT the same as debated earlier in another post.





------------------

[[EC]Mjr. Winters]

they dont even have the same cloths.... its not the same guy

[Trench]

I was gonna post stuff in the topic on this matter but I would have just been repeating stuff other people said. Well done Quik, those pics should clear everything up

------------------


Achtung! (Still looking for an Axis Squad)

[EaSyTrIcK50]

But then why the hell does Upham shoot Steamboat willie at the end, and why the hell does the Nazi let Upham live? Although the uniforms prove it, it doesn't make a lick of sense, that is just bad movie making, as a matter of fact, I don't think I like SPR anymore. I mean the whole revenge thing was the good part.

------------------
"God I hate Nazi Trains ever so Much!!!"


"The Only Time You Worry About A Soldier Is When He Stops Bitching"

[[AoD]Jobi1]

I agree easy, it doesn't make much sense.

[Dasher]

Ack

[This message has been edited by Dasher (edited January 27, 2002).]

[Dasher]

EaSyTrIcK50
<BLOCKQUOTE><font size="1" face="Tahoma, Verdana, Arial">quote:</font><HR>But then why the hell does Upham shoot Steamboat willie at the end<HR></BLOCKQUOTE>
Because he sees steamboat shoot CPT.Miller!
Just watch the movie and you'll get Why!

------------------
You feel like dying today don't ya?!

[sgt.sayian]

OK! LETS SETTLE THIS ONCE AND FOR ALL!!!

SOMEONE WATCH THE END CREDITS !!!!! LOL

[Quik]

I think the reason that the SS soldier let Upham live is that he knew that Upham could have killed him when he was fighting with Fish and some how felt sorry for him?? Just my .02.....

------------------

[Trench]

I feel the same way Quik, some people in war realize that they need to kill others just because when it comes down to the line the people on the other end will kill you to live. but when upham was on the stairs and the SS soldier came down, it was sort of a emotional thing that happened. the SS soldier understood upham was upset about being there, and what is happening around him ,and knew upham wouldent do anything since he removed his hand from his rifle, so he just left. IMOH , if that SS soldier was me, I seriously would have shot upham the instant i saw him on the stairs without giving it second thought. If I had just been in a small fight with two allied soldiers in a room in a building like that, and being the ONLY one who survived out of 5 people (3 germans, 2 allied) I would have made it my buisness to know if more allied troops are coming into the building cause they might be coming to check up on what happened. Once I would have seen upham, I might have thought there would be more behind him and shot him on the stairs and made my way out as fast as possible. I wouldent have even stopped to look at him like the SS soldier did, and wait to see what happens, upham would have been dead in 1 second if that was me

------------------


Achtung! (Still looking for an Axis Squad)

[This message has been edited by Trench (edited January 27, 2002).]

[sgt.sayian]

but trench, the SS had his rifle on his shoulder and wouldn't have time

If I was upham I would have ran up and beat the fuck out of the ss with my rifle butt.
But anyone can say they would run up and shoot the SS, but you have to realize its war, its alot of phycological shit.

My grandpa was in WWII and said there was alot of scary shit over in Belguim fighting for the canadian infantry army. He said he saw a german sniper and didn't know to shoot or not and all told me was we both made eye contact and look whos here now.
but not to get off topic here Upgham was a Translator and really wasn't ment to fight the war since he did not have any experience.
Bad mistake to bring Upham into a Ranger group who was gonna be stoping Romel's first wave to cross the bridge (considering the squad didnt know they were)