just saw this one last night, very good flick. especially if you have developed a general hatred for women ( i have ) .
i saw ebert & "roeper" give this one a shitty review, and had that in the back of my mind the whole time ... even still it was a leet flick. I had already read the short story so i knew what was going on (sadly). it wouldve been much better if i hadnt read it ...
I saw it sometime last week - thought it was very good... as i hadnt read the book - i had no idea what was happening and was very suprised with the ending.... a good ending to a good story.
i never listen to film reviewers, they all suck ass, they only like the movies that bore the hell out of you like the english patiant or some gay shit like that. i remember sickle and ebert gave star wars 2 thumbs down, they are idiots. secret window was good. mystic river a way better movie just saw last night.