[Miscguy]

Doom 3 was good for what it was. Its not my kind of shooter though. I prefer open spaces and walking down coridor after coridor just gets old pretty fast. There were a few nice points in the game, but over all a bit out dated gameplay wise.

HL2 on the other hand is exceptional for what it is. The story can be a bit complex at times, trying to figure out WTF is going on and why. It accomplishes everything valve set out to do, it set a new standard with ass loads of new features and stunning graphics. The only reason it beats doom3 is its level design, and gameplay.

I doubt the expansion will offer enough good stuff to tollerate another go at doom3. Though i do love the double shotty.