1 Giant Leap. - Page 5

Chappy · 07-25-2005, 07:06 AM

[quote="Short Hand":c647c] Not to mention many cases of Homosexaulity are genetic....So yes it comes natural.[/quote:c647c]

and you have proof for this? as far as i know, they are only saying that some people are "predisposed" to be homosexual just as some people are "predisposed" to be alcoholics or others are "predisposed" to like vanilla ice cream over chocolate ice cream...the "gay gene" has yet to be found.

being someone who has been called to religion, I have no problem with civil unions so that folks can have the same benefits as heterosexual couples such as being able to jointly file taxes and insurance etc., my problem comes from gay couples demanding that the church "bless" their union. i could give two craps less what you people feel about religion but for those of us who practice it...we are not homophobic. you can love people without condoning their behavior. i don't agree with that life style, just as i dont agree with men who cheat on their wives as a viable and healthy life style.

you just have to live with the fact that there are some people who don't agree with you on this one, short and because they don't does not mean that they will hate or condone violence against people who choose to live like that

Short Hand · 07-25-2005, 07:45 AM

Umm......most gays do not "demands" the blessing from the catholic, Protestant, Baptist, Anglican, Presbiteryian, Methodist, or any other church. All the ask is for Marriage. Christians did not invent the whole idea of Marriage, it is a VERY ancient ceremony. Not something you can declare a monopoly on for hetrosexauls. I fail to see a single gay activists group ask for the Catholic church to perform their ceremony. rolleyes:

(Also note I was a "PRACTICING CATHOLIC" for over 15 years since I was born. I know what it means and how much bullshit it really is)

-Homosexaulity is genetic, but not inherited" Heritable does not mean "inherited", so in fact Homosexaulity is a mixture of genetics and psychology. Your upbringing has just as much effect as your genes do.... or that is at least what current studies are suggesting in this ever so changing world. (of course any reputable genetics studys only concentrate on direct inheritence.....like eye colour or your height). For the most part, studys are inconclusive, no one can really boast about the answer.

-Not quite proof of the gay gene, but a excellent read into it.

http://members.aol.com/gaygene/pages/standard.htm

I found the stances section rather intresting

[quote="Is There a "Gay Gene"?":5fac8] Ever since homosexuality became an issue in the United States 30 years ago or so, there have been three competing positions on it.

Position 1: Homosexuality is a chosen "lifestyle," like vegetarianism.

Position 2: Homosexuality is a disease, like schizophrenia.

Position 3: Homosexuality is a biological orientation, like left-handedness, and is neither chosen nor pathological.

Secular conservatives tend to accept Position 1 and/or Position 2, which means that every new piece of lab research on the gay gene sets their teeth on edge. But say that science had concluded Position 3 was a matter of fact. There is no question that conservatives would suffer a short-term loss; it is always painful when you have committed yourself to a belief that is literally proved untrue, and enemies of conservatism would play "gotcha" for a while.

But what the Right fails to comprehend is that a conservatism unremittingly hostile to homosexuality and *truly committed to the resurgence of conservative thought with real impact on public policy can, and should, embrace the gay gene, which will bring conservatives two long-term gains.[/quote:5fac8]

KTOG · 07-25-2005, 07:48 AM

My gay friend has the best quote on this:

"Homosexuality is Gods way of ensuring that the truly gifted and classy folks are not burdened with children."

Johnj · 07-25-2005, 07:59 AM

Then again you could just cut your balls off with a rusty dull knife and achieve the same results.

ed:

Chappy · 07-25-2005, 08:04 AM

[quote="Short Hand":40cef]Umm......most gays do not "demands" the blessing from the catholic, Protestant, Baptist, Anglican, Presbiteryian, Methodist, or any other church. All the ask is for Marriage. Christians did not invent the whole idea of Marriage, it is a VERY ancient ceremony. Not something you can declare a monopoly on for hetrosexauls. I fail to see a single gay activists group ask for the Catholic church to perform their ceremony. rolleyes:

(Also note I was a "PRACTICING CATHOLIC" for over 15 years since I was born. I know what it means and how much bullshit it really is)

[/quote:40cef]

you don't work in a church and don't practice your "bullshit" faith anymore so you have no idea the crapstorm that is flying around most protestant (not so much catholic) congregations. because you don't then you don't see the gay activist groups that target protestants specifically in order to have gay marriage sanctioned by the church, not to mention more homosexuals in leadership positions (on par with the marriage issue). most denominations are having to play damage control in order that certain groups don't split their churches down the middle.

like i said, i could care less how you feel about religion, im not forcing mine down anyone's throat, so i feel its only fair that i not be called a "homophobe" because i dont agree. you can call practicing faith "bullshit" all you want...that doesn't change anything; what you do and what you believe in your life is your business...don't try and make it mine. (its cool to be gay but not cool to be a person of faith...wtf kind of logic is that? liberals want all people to be equal, unless youre a conservative who believes in God...nice system you got there) why is it that when put up for votes, the majority of people in a majority of states vote against mandating gay marriage? because America is a bunch of gay bashing hatemongers? no, they just don't want the issue forced down their throats like it has been, and they don't think its a civil rights issue but a lifestyle choice that has been turned into a socio-political debate...until you can prove that homosexuality is absolutely hereditary, you have no scientific ground to stand on.

and all of those articles you posted still cannot prove that there is a "gay gene" only predispositions of it...who does those studies? all studies and cases are peformed by people, people have bias and reasons behind doing the studies...it has nothing to do with conservative thought vs liberal thought

liberals want everyone to believe they fight for the good of mankind until someone doesnt buy into their crusade and then they are labeled "homophobes"

Pyro · 07-25-2005, 02:36 PM

The point of marriage is not to reproduce...we are not obligated to reproduce in our lifetime...

Id like to get married, like to know Ive had at least a kid to see what ti is like...but im not obligated too. Marriage doens't mean you need to have babies.

and fuck i don't know what id do if I ever get some bitch pregnant befor eim married.

c312 · 07-25-2005, 03:16 PM

homosexuality is not genetic.

Being raised a certain way could make it a lot easier for someone to be gay, but it isn't in the genes.

KTOG · 07-25-2005, 03:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by c312

homosexuality is not genetic.

Being raised a certain way could make it a lot easier for someone to be gay, but it isn't in the genes.

proof?

c312 · 07-25-2005, 03:41 PM

burden of proof is on the person who claimed it was genetic... show me an article that states the discovery of the gay chromosome and I'll change my statement.

1080jibber · 07-25-2005, 03:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by c312

burden of proof is on the person who claimed it was genetic... show me an article that states the discovery of the gay chromosome and I'll change my statement.

Show me proof that there is a god first happy:

c312 · 07-25-2005, 03:49 PM

we weren't talking about God, why do I need to prove him to you.

1080jibber · 07-25-2005, 03:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by c312

we weren't talking about God, why do I need to prove him to you.

but it all comes down to god, if it didnt then who cares about gay getting married. why do you need to prove him to me? well im the kind of guy that likes the facts, with funding we can find out if being gay is genetic or not.

c312 · 07-25-2005, 04:01 PM

read "Mere Christianity" if you are into logic. It's written by CS Lewis who was an atheist then reason led him to accepting there was a God.

if you are scientific, read "Darwin's Black Box"

and proving if there is or isn't a God doesn't make a difference in whether or not homosexuality is natural or not.

1080jibber · 07-25-2005, 04:06 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by c312

and proving if there is or isn't a God doesn't make a difference in whether or not homosexuality is natural or not.

but it does, if it is choosen then it would be a sin, but if its genetic, then what is it?

c312 · 07-25-2005, 04:16 PM

no, you don't understand.

Right now, I am arguing that homosexuality is not natural, that's all, just that it is not genetic. God is not in the argument at this point at all, just scientific facts.