[CoMaToSe]

I have played both series, and truly cannot decide which reigns superior. Please only post if you have played/are familiar with both series. I would do a poll, but It would be very complicated, spanning (and spamming) many threads to do so. this has the various aspects and my vote (if any)

Which has better:

Graphics

Vehicles (Halo)

Weapons

Enemy AI

Friendly AI (Half-life)

Maps (Halo)

Story

Music (Halo)

Sound

Physics (Half-Life)

Characters

Cooler Armor

"Drama" factor (Halo)

"Scare" Factor (Half-Life)

Gameplay

Potential for a Movie

Overall

[lasagna]

half life 2, no doubt in my mind.

[geRV]

Graphics = Halflife 2

Vehicles = Halo 2

Weapons = Halflife2 marginally because of the manipulator gun

Enemy ai = Halo 2

Friendly ai = They both are equally bad

Maps = Halflife 2

Story = Equally good story so far imo

Music = Halo 2

Characters = Halflife 2

Armor ( eek: ) = Halo 2

Drama = Halflife 2

Scarefactor = Halflife 2

Movie potential = Either could be good movies

Overall both good games that have abrupt endings that pissed off the fanbase.

Shoulda stuck doom 3 into this as well, 3 most hyped games of the year.

[ninty]

I've passed both games:


Graphics: HL

Vehicles: Halo

Weapons: HL

Enemy AI: HL

Friendly AI: HL

Maps: HL

Story; Halo

Music: Halo

Sound: HL

Physics: HL

Characters: Tie

Cooler Armor: Is there even any armour in HL?

"Drama" factor: Halo

"Scare" Factor: HL

Gameplay: HL

Potential for a Movie: Halo

Overall: HL

[geRV]

The hazard suit is basically the armor in hl2.

[ninty]

Oh yeah, true enough.

[CoMaToSe]

Originally Posted by geRV

Armor ( eek: ) = Halo 2

Cooler looking: Gordon's HEV versus Master Chief's MJOLNIR

Has anybody played "Codename: Gordon"? I have some advice for you.
Unless you like sarcastic, poorly controlled 2D shit, avoid

[CoMaToSe]

I forgot a criterion: Multiplayer

I think HL deathmatch and CS:S are way better than either Halo MP

Graphics: Half Life 2

Vehicles: Halo 2

Weapons: Half Life 2

Enemy AI: Half Life 2

Friendly AI: Halo 2

Maps: Half Life 2

Story: Half Life 2 (The whole HL story is cool)

Music: Halo 2

Sound: Half Life 2

Physics: Half Life 2

Characters: Half Life 2

Cooler Armor: Halo 2 (helmet = rock

"Drama" factor: Half Life 2

"Scare" Factor: Half Life 2 (Halo 2 isnt ment to be scary)

Gameplay: Half Life 2

Potential for a Movie: both

Overall: Half Life 2 blew away Halo 2 but thats PC vs Console...

[Milla]

HL2 > Halo

[elstatec]

Graphics = hl2

Vehicles =halo

Weapons = sword from halo>you

Enemy AI = eeee, halo 2, fucken too many!

Friendly AI = hl2 as the friendly ai in halo are lazy and die alot.

Maps = halo

Story = errrr draw for me

Music = halo

Sound = halo

Physics =hl2

Characters = those little dudes in halo 2 rock:

Cooler Armor = dont care.

"Drama" factor- halo

"Scare" Factor - mhm scare~? psh.

Gameplay -= halo2

Potential for a Movie - neither, game2movies suck.

Overall - halo as the multiplayer is the most fun ever ever ever.

then again you cant really compare these games as halo 2 is restricted by the xboxs capabilities.

[Maplegyver]

hl2>halo in all aspects.

[elstatec]

Originally Posted by maple

hl2>halo in all aspects.

go play mario, chuck sleeping:

[Maplegyver]

Originally Posted by elstatec

go play mario, chuck sleeping:

not into mario.

[Pyro]

Id say niether is even close to being considered the best game series.